Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law Logo Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law

You are here: Publications Periodic Publications of the Institute Heidelberg Journal of International Law Abstracts of the last 4 Issues

Abstracts of the last 4 Issues

Interpretation in Accordance with International Law from a Swiss Point of View: a Marginal Phenomenon?

This article discusses the scope and limits of consistent interpretation in Switzerland and discusses the extent to which construing national law in conformity with public international law is indicative of the ‘friendliness towards international law’ of a constitution. I argue, first, that consistent interpretation in Switzerland has certainly served the cause of friendliness towards international law, but that three conditions must be met before consistent interpretation can come into play. Second, the article concludes that consistent interpretation is, nevertheless, of limited use in ‘measuring’ the international law friendliness of the Swiss legal system because consistent interpretation does not come into play in numerous constellations and narrows the view to a modest number of court cases. In relation to the sum of challenges related to the implementation of international law domestically, consistent interpretation is a marginal phenomenon.

[back]