Max-Planck-Institut für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht Logo Max-Planck-Institut für ausländisches öffentliches Recht und Völkerrecht

Sie befinden sich hier: Forschen am Institut Gesprächs- und Arbeitsformate Gesprächskreise Theory Talks

Theory Talks

Ansprechpartner: Silvia Steininger, Tom Sparks

 

Der Gesprächskreis Theory Talks bietet Wissenschaftler*innen und Gästen am Max-Planck-Institut die Möglichkeit zur Diskussion über Fragen der Rechts-, Moral-, und politischen Theorie. Der Gesprächskreis findet dabei im Stil eines Seminars ein Mal im Monat statt, jeweils mit einer kurzen Einführung (10-15 Minuten) gefolgt von einer allgemeinen Diskussion. In jedem Treffen steht eine neue Publikation, ein klassischer Text, oder eine gegenwärtige Entwicklung. Jede*r ist herzlich willkommen!

Informationen zu früheren Veranstaltungen des GK finden Sie im Archiv.

 

Falls Sie gerne im Rahmen der Theory Talks vorstellen möchten, wenden Sie sich bitte an .

Programm

23 January 2020 - 15.30-17.30

Raphael Oidtmann

The “Geographical Pivot of History” Revisited – On the Interplay of Geopolitics and International Law

Geopolitics has (re-)emerged as both an explanatory pattern and analytical framework in contemporary international relations over the last years: phenomena such as shrinking ice masses in the Arctic or processes like gradual desertification have hence revived deliberations on the role and effects of (geographical) space(s) within international politics more broadly.
The interplay between geopolitics and international law, however, has oftentimes been neglected in this context: how can power-based “classical” geopolitics thus be reconciled with (international) legal reasoning? What answers does international law hold for fundamental geopolitical categories, such as frontiers, space(s) or spheres of influence? And how could it be possible to harmonize these sometimes-contradictory intellectual planes?
The required readings for the session are supposed to fulfil two broad objectives: in a first step, the notion of geopolitics as originally conceptualized by authors such as Mackinder will be introduced (while acknowledging its distinct historical context) before the second reading expounds some points of contact between geopolitical and international legal reasoning, which will subsequently form the basis for the plenary discussion.


Required Reading:

  • Mackinder, Halford (1904): The Geographical Pivot of History, The Geographical Journal, Vol. 23(4), 421-444 (reprinted in The Geographical Journal, Vol. 170(4), 298-321).
  • Orakhelashvili, Alexander (2008): International Law and Geopolitics: One Object, Conflicting Legitimacies?, Netherland Yearbook of International Law, Vol. 39, 155-204 (in particular subsections VI and VII).

Further Reading:

  • Knutsen, Torbjorn L. (2014): Halford J. Mackinder, Geopolitics, and the Heartland Thesis, The International History Review, Vol. 36(5), 835-857.
  • Moore, Thomas (2013): Saving Friends or Saving Strangers? Critical Humanitarianism and the Geopolitics of International Law, Review of International Studies, Vol. 39(4), 925-947.
  • Müllerson, Rein (2016): Ideology, Geopolitics and International Law, Chinese Journal of International Law, Vol. 15(1), 47-73

Popular Reading:

  • Kaplan, Robert D. (2017): Earning the Rockies: How Geography Shapes America’s Role in the World, Random House.
  • Marshall, Tim (2016): Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps That Explain Everything About the World, Scribner.

 

6 February 2020 - 15.30-17.30

Gunther Teubner

Social Theory and Legal Doctrine: Transversal Paradoxes

Required reading

  • "Law & Social Theory: Three Problems", 1 Asian Journal of Law and Society 2 (2014) 235-254

Optional reading

  • "Quod omnes tangit: Transnational Constitutions without Democracy?", 57 Der Staat 2 (2018) 171-194
  • "Regime-Collisions: The Vain Search for Legal Unity in the Fragmentation of Global Law", 25 Michigan Journal of International Law 4 (2004) 999-1046 (zusammen mit Andreas Fischer-Lescano)

Background reading

  • "Matrix Reloaded: Kritik der staatszentrischen Drittwirkung der Grundrechte am Beispiel des Publication Bias", 47 Kritische Justiz (2014) 150-168 (zusammen mit Isabell Hensel)

 

 

2 July - 15.30-17.30

Ntina Tzouvala

International Law and Racial Capitalism